Skip to content
Admin sign in
GMGRAY MATTER HR
ServicesPricingTrainingLatest postsFree resourcesCase lawMeet LisaLog a caseClient sign inEnquire now
All latest posts

Flexible working · 26 October 2026

Declining a flexible working request? Can your managers evidence their decision?

By Lisa Gray · Originally shared on Facebook

Gray Matter HR graphic about evidencing flexible working decisions
The original Gray Matter HR post graphic.

A statutory flexible working request is an employee exercising a legal right. Managers need to understand the responsibilities that come with responding.

A refusal must be based on one or more of the eight permitted business reasons. Managers should be able to explain how the reason applies to the individual request and what supports their conclusion.

Before declining, consider

  • Operational impact: What specific work, hours or service requirements would be affected?
  • Evidence: What do staffing levels, workload, customer demand or cost estimates show?
  • Alternatives: Could different hours, reorganised duties or a trial period address the concerns?
  • Consultation: Has the employee had a meaningful opportunity to discuss concerns and suggest solutions? Consultation must happen before refusal.
  • Wider implications: Consider the impact on the employee and business, potential benefits, discrimination risks and any reasonable adjustment duties.

The written outcome should connect the request, the assessment, the business reason and the decision.

Training managers to assess requests thoroughly—and document their reasoning—is essential to good decision-making.

View the original Facebook post

Further reading · checked 9 November 2026

  • Acas: considering a statutory flexible working request

Need support with a people matter?

Practical, independent HR support for your next decision.

Make an enquiry
GMGRAY MATTER HR

Because HR matters are never black and white.

Enquire nowLog a caseClient portalTrainingLatest postsFree resourcesCase lawPrivacyAdmin sign in